Skip to product information
1 of 14

๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ธ American Made

13 total reviews

Tallow Eye Cream | Coffee Infused Under Eye Cream 2 oz

Quick Summary
Lavender and Vanilla whipped tallow moisturizers made with grass-fed tallow to deeply hydrate, nourish, and soften dry skin.
Regular price
$29.00
Regular price
$32.00
Sale price
$29.00
Shipping calculated at checkout.
    Purchase options
    $29.00
    -10%
    -10%from$26.10/ month-10%
    Auto-reorder Frequency
    Delivery every month
    -10%
    -10%
    $26.10/ month
    -10%
    ๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ธ Handcrafted in Mississippi
    ๐Ÿฎ Grass-Fed Tallow
    ๐Ÿšš Fast Shipping
    %3Cp%3EEarn%20%3Cstrong%3E[points_amount]%3C/strong%3E%20when%20you%20buy%20this%20item.%20%3C/p%3E
    Description

    Lady May Natural Tallow Eye Cream | Coffee-Infused Under Eye Moisturizer 2 oz

    Give your eyes the care they deserve with Lady May Coffee-Infused Tallow Eye Cream โ€” a rich, handcrafted formula designed to hydrate and refresh delicate under-eye skin. Made with nutrient-dense grass-fed tallow and infused with coffee bean extract using the traditional Enfleurage method, this eye cream delivers natural nourishment with a smooth, non-greasy finish.

    Perfect for daily use, it locks in moisture, softens skin, and supports a naturally bright, well-rested appearance.

    Pure & Natural Benefits

    • Hydrating Care: Deeply moisturizes and smooths delicate under-eye skin.

    • Coffee Infusion: Naturally refreshing botanical extract.

    • Nutrient-Dense: Packed with vitamins A, D, E, and K plus fatty acids.

    • Lightweight Texture: Absorbs quickly without greasiness.

    • Gentle Formula: Free from preservatives, parabens, and synthetic additives.

    • Versatile Use: Also great for soothing dry patches on sensitive areas.

    Product Specifications

    • Key Ingredients: Grass-Fed Beef Tallow, Coffee Bean Extract, Jojoba Oil, Vitamin E

    • Size: 2 oz eco-friendly glass jar

    • Texture: Rich yet fast-absorbing cream

    • Preservative-free and handmade in the USA

    • Suitable for all skin types, including sensitive

    Perfect For

    • Daily under-eye hydration

    • Softening fine, delicate skin

    • Adding natural care to your skincare routine

    • Sensitive skin that needs a gentle, fragrance-free formula

    Sustainable Features

    • Ethically sourced beef tallow

    • Small-batch, handcrafted in the USA

    • Eco-friendly packaging

    • No synthetic fillers or artificial preservatives

    How to use

    Apply a small amount to clean skin and massage gently until absorbed. Use daily on the face, hands, elbows, legs, or anywhere your skin needs extra hydration.

    Ingredients

    Vanilla: Grass-Fed Beef Tallow, Vanilla Absolute Oil
    Lavender: Grass-Fed Beef Tallow, Lavender Essential Oil, Natural Lavender Extracts

    Shipping information

    Lady May Tallow

    Shipping Rate Calculated on Check Out

    • Order processing Time 2-4 business days.
    • Standard delivery: 3-5 business days.
    Return Policy

    Lady May Tallow

    30 Day-Limited free returns only onย unopened/unused products.ย 

    Contact usย for instructions.

    Authorized Retailer Statement

    My American Goodsยฎ is an authorized retailer of Lady May Tallow. Select items are fulfilled by My American Goodsยฎ from our fulfillment center, while others ship directly from the maker. All products are authentic and sourced from Lady May Tallow official inventory. Learn More.

    Tallow Eye Cream | Coffee Infused Under Eye Cream 2 oz
    Tallow Eye Cream | Coffee Infused Under Eye Cream 2 oz
    Tallow Eye Cream | Coffee Infused Under Eye Cream 2 oz
    Tallow Eye Cream | Coffee Infused Under Eye Cream 2 oz
    Tallow Eye Cream | Coffee Infused Under Eye Cream 2 oz
    Tallow Eye Cream | Coffee Infused Under Eye Cream 2 oz
    Tallow Eye Cream | Coffee Infused Under Eye Cream 2 oz
    Tallow Eye Cream | Coffee Infused Under Eye Cream 2 oz
    Tallow Eye Cream | Coffee Infused Under Eye Cream 2 oz
    Tallow Eye Cream | Coffee Infused Under Eye Cream 2 oz
    Tallow Eye Cream | Coffee Infused Under Eye Cream 2 oz
    Tallow Eye Cream | Coffee Infused Under Eye Cream 2 oz
    Tallow Eye Cream | Coffee Infused Under Eye Cream 2 oz
    • Made in USA

    • Lady May Tallow Shipping Rate Calculated at Check Out

    • My American Goodsยฎ Certified Quality

    • Sustainably Made

    • Small Business Brand

    Lady May Tallow Body Cream/Lotion Bay Rum Beard & Body Butter for Men | Natural Tallow Moisturizer
    Curated by My American Goodsยฎ

    The Story behind Lady May Tallow

    Lady May Tallow stands out because it brings a traditional ingredient back into everyday care with a clear sense of purpose. The brandโ€™s story began with a simple experiment โ€” turning tallow into something useful for the skin โ€” and grew into a full line of hand-poured tallow skincare, soaps, balms, and candles rooted in old-fashioned care.

    What makes Lady May especially aligned with My American Goodsยฎ is its focus on family-owned production, small-batch craftsmanship, and traditional methods. The brand describes itself as a family-owned business committed to small-batch production, transparency, and quality, with products handcrafted in the USA using grass-fed beef tallow and organic oils.

    This is not skincare built around a complicated 10-step routine. Itโ€™s a brand centered on heritage, simplicity, and ingredients people recognize โ€” from whipped moisturizers to cleansing balms and candles. Lady May Tallow fits My American Goodsยฎ because it represents American-made essentials, traditional craftsmanship, and care that feels personal rather than mass-produced.

    Shop Lady May Tallow

    Lady May Tallow FAQs

    What is Lady May Tallow known for?

    Lady May Tallow is known for tallow-based skincare, including whipped tallow moisturizers, lip balms, tallow soaps, cleansers, candles, menโ€™s grooming products, and body care essentials.

    What makes their tallow different?

    The brand says its tallow is wet-rendered without additives or preservatives, creating an odorless base while keeping the ingredient simple and traditional.

    Does tallow skincare need to be refrigerated?

    No โ€” Lady May Tallow says its natural tallow products are shelf-stable at room temperature, though they can be refrigerated or frozen to extend shelf life.

    Does tallow have a beefy smell?

    According to Lady May Tallow, their wet-rendering process helps purify the tallow and leave it odorless.

    How should tallow skincare be stored?

    Store tallow products away from direct light and major temperature changes. Lady May recommends a typical temperature-controlled environment around 68โ€“74ยฐF to help maintain texture.

    Who are these products best for?

    Theyโ€™re best for customers looking for simple, traditional body care made with recognizable ingredients and a more minimal skincare routine.

    Coffee-infused tallow eye cream with natural ingredients. Customers said it "smells amazing" like coffee and provides excellent moisture. Many reported reduced dark circles, puffiness, and brightened under-eyes. The thick, creamy texture absorbs well though some found it heavy. A little goes a long way, making the 2oz jar last.

    • Coffee extract minimizes dark circles! Best eye creams I have used at such an affordable price!
    • Smells amazing! Feels luxurious! Love to support a small business with quality products.
    • A little dab under each eye does it. Makes my skin feel very soft and silky once absorbed.
    Moisture (positive)Cream (positive)Skin (positive)Texture (positive)Circles (positive)
    • 5 stars: 11 (85%)
    • 4 stars: 2 (15%)
    • 3 stars: 0 (0%)
    • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
    • 1 star: 0 (0%)
    C
    Carol H.
    Coffee extract minimizes dark circles!

    I have tried many products, that claim to minimize dark undereye circles, with no results, until I tried this coffee-infused tallow cream from Lady May. It comes in a small jar, but a little goes a long way. I love the creamy texture and the way it feels on my undereye skin. I have deep set eyes and have always had a problem with dark circles. I need to be careful what products I use because I have fair skin, and the skin under my eyes is very delicate and thin. The cream is very moisturizing and makes my skin feel soft, smooth and silky while also giving me the benefit of the coffee extract ingredient that helps minimize dark circles. I have used many Lady May creams, and each one is amazing. This tallow eye cream has also minimized fine lines around my eyes, and it brightens the eye area. I have been applying the cream both in the morning and at night, and it keeps my skin hydrated for 24 hours while also minimizing the darkness under my eyes. The scent of coffee is mildly strong and I love it! It does dissipate after a while if this is something you're not fond of. This has to be one of the best eye creams I have used and at such an affordable price!

    d
    dubled
    All natural coffee infused eye cream that seems well made.

    This 2 ounce container of coffee infused eye cream is made with tallow as its main ingredient. Tallow seems to be all the rage these days with moisturizing. This eye cream does go on smooth and seems to get absorbed well. This coffee infused eye cream certainly does smell like coffee, some people may think itโ€™s a bit too much.One thing I was concerned about with putting this near my eyes would be any kind of eye irritation that might occur. But I did not experience anything like that. After using it for a couple days, I noticed no ill effects of it or any irritation. Itโ€™s hard for me to say if thereโ€™s a difference near my eyes as far as puffiness. The eye cream does feel good with it on and if nothing else it is providing good moisturizing.I like the fact that it is it natural moisturizer and the fact it contains 4 different vitamins. It also has rosehip oil and honey. The coffee bean extract is infused into it and itโ€™s supposed to help with puffiness. Even though this is only a 2 ounce container I believe this should last for quite some time. Each day you use it I donโ€™t think youโ€™re using very much. Itโ€™s a very small amount that needs to go around your eyes.

    k
    kayla
    Lady May Coffee-Infused Tallow Eye Cream Review

    Review of: Lady May Coffee-Infused Tallow Eye CreamI am so amazed at how quickly this eye cream worked for me!I don't get the most sleep, so I typically have lines and bags under my eyes. However, today I attended the memorial for my father to celebrate his life of 90 years. It was very emotional for me and I cried almost the entire time.When I got home, my eyes were puffy and swollen. But after applying this eye cream, I saw the results almost instantly.The smell is amazing and it does not irritate my skin at all..This is a wonderful eye cream that produces results almost instantaneously!

    R
    Rachel G.
    Smells Amazing, Feels Great Around Eyes- Mine Arrived Open

    This tallow eye cream infused with coffee smells absolutely incredible, like a freshly brewed pot of coffee. I really wanted to give this product the benefit of the doubt because the formula itself is so moisturizing and soothing. Unfortunately, mine arrived open, and most of the cream had leaked out and soaked into the box. What was left in the jar was melted and soupy, though after letting it sit for a day, it did firm back up. There just isnโ€™t much left to use.That said, the cream that is in the jar feels wonderful. Itโ€™s very hydrating around the eyes and works beautifully on dry patches, leaving my skin smooth and nourished. I really like the product; I wish more of it had made it into the jar for me to continue using.

    C
    Customer R.
    A Little Dab Under Each Eye Does It

    First of all I love the scent of this Lady May Tallow eye cream which smells lightly of espresso. Beyond this pleasant fragrance I really love how this cream performs in my under eye areas. I take a small bit on my finger and I can massage the modest amount of lotion into both areas under my eyes. So, even though the jar is small it will last a long time. The lotion makes my skin feel very soft and silky once the cream gets fully absorbed. I can see the difference in the skin firmness in this area but I haven't seen too much change in the skin tone, which is fine as I really am using it for the ability of the cream to soften and slightly tighten the areas where applied.

    M
    Mac
    Itโ€™s like a shot of espresso for your eye baggage!!

    Been using this eye cream for 5-6 years now! Love it.

    A
    Aura
    Marvelous

    Smells amazing! Feels luxurious! Love the extra care put into packaging, especially with our Texas heat. Also love to support a small business with a great story and quality products.

    S
    S
    Great addition to my morning skin routine, leaves under eyes soft and brightened

    I've really liked adding this tallow eye cream to my morning skin prep. With two kids and one on the way, my eyes can always use a little extra brightening. The cream is definitely on the thicker side, so I just use a little bit of product under each eye. I feel like it really wakes up my under eyes and makes my skin look moisturized. I let it dry down as much as possible before applying other products and it works nicely.

    B
    Beauty L.
    Moisturizing, soothing and wakes up my under-eye areas.

    I love this Lady May Tallow eye cream, as it is coffee-infused. This cream is very helpful for me in the mornings, when I look tired. The cream absorbs nicely onto my skin, and provides moisture and a nice glow to my under-eye areas.I find that this cream is a nice quality, and is gentle on my skin. There's not much of a scent that I can detect, but maybe that's just me. I love how this cream helps with puffiness and dark circles under my eyes, and illuminates my skin in a lovely way.I think this is a great skincare product, and after just a few uses, I've already seen some positive results. I'm continuing to use this cream in the mornings, or any time my skin needs a pick-me-up.I do think this is a nice value for the price point, as a little bit goes a long way. I'm very happy I ordered this product, and would recommend it to others.

    m
    mervissa
    Creamy and has a light coffee scent

    This is a nice light textured whipped tallow eye cream that can be used for all over your face or even your body. Just be careful how much you apply as it can get greasy. Itโ€™s made with natural ingredients to include tallow, manuka honey, rosehip oil, and coffee extract. It feels nice and creamy and absorbs quickly. This moisturizer definitely has a light coffee scent, but thankfully, it dissipates once absorbed. The coffee bean extract helped to reduce puffiness and dark circles, along with essential vitamins that help firm the skin and make it look healthier. Overall, this is a nice eye cream that can be used anywhere to help with dark spots and add instant hydration.

    C
    Cliente d.K.
    RรPIDA ABSOSIร“N

    Me encanta, es suave, mi piel amance suave sin tirones, sobre todo en este clima la siento hidratada y sin sensibilidad.. La seguirรฉ usando.

    T
    Tamara
    Great product for the price

    Really love this eye cream. You need to use very little, hope to be able to use it all before it goes bad.

    I
    IlikeAmazon
    Love it

    This wonderful eye and face cream. Love the light coffee smell also. I always get compliments on my skin. In my 70s. Iโ€™ve given it as gifts and everyone loves it.

    Lady May Tallow Moments

    #myamericangoods