Refund policy

MY AMERICAN GOODS®   |   CUSTOMER CARE

Returns & Refunds, Made Simple

We want you to shop confidently while supporting the independent American brands and makers behind our marketplace. Here's how to request a return and find the policy that applies to your purchase.

Sign In to Start a Return →

Return requests are reviewed before approval. Please do not mail anything back until you've received authorization.

30 days

Standard eligible return window

7 days

Report damage, defects, or errors

Approval first

Wait for instructions before shipping

How to Start a Return

Our return process begins in your My American Goods® customer account. You don't need to contact an individual maker or initiate a return directly from an order.

  1. Sign in. Open your customer account using the email address associated with your purchase.
  2. Select "Start a Return." Find it in the left-hand account menu (or open your account navigation menu on mobile).
  3. Complete the request form. Enter the order and item details, explain why you're requesting a return, and upload photographs if requested. The menu takes you to our Return Items form.
  4. Wait for our review. If approved, we'll send the applicable return instructions. Do not ship merchandise before authorization.

Sign In to Start a Return →

FIND "START A RETURN" IN YOUR ACCOUNT MENU

My American Goods customer account navigation highlighting the Start a Return menu option

Your account layout may look slightly different on mobile.

Before sending anything back: All requests require review and authorization. Items mailed without approval may be refused or returned to you at your expense. Submitting a form does not automatically qualify an item for a refund.

Find the Answer You Need

Select a topic to jump to its section below. All policy terms remain visible for reference.

01. What is the return window?

Our standard policy allows eligible items to be returned within 30 calendar days of the delivery date recorded by the carrier.

Because My American Goods® features independent makers, certain products follow the maker's own return terms. When a different policy is shown on the product page, that maker-specific policy takes precedence, subject to applicable law.

Not every product is eligible for return, even within the standard window.

02. What condition must my return be in?

To qualify for a standard return, the product must be in the same condition in which you received it:

  • Unworn, unused, unwashed, and unaltered
  • All tags, labels, protective seals, accessories, and inserts intact
  • Original packaging included, such as branded boxes, dust bags, jars, bottles, sleeves, wraps, or protective components
  • Receipt, order confirmation, or other proof of purchase available

Items showing signs of wear, washing, alteration, installation, scent use, broken seals, missing packaging, or damage after delivery may be ineligible for a refund and returned at the customer's expense.

03. Which items cannot be returned?

The following categories are generally non-returnable or final sale:

  • Food, beverages, and consumables: pantry goods, honey, coffee, tea, snacks, perishables, and similar items
  • Opened or used personal care: skincare, cosmetics, fragrances, soap, bath, body, wellness, deodorant, hair care, beauty, and grooming products that have been opened, tested, sampled, or used
  • Items with broken seals or missing protective packaging
  • Customized, personalized, engraved, monogrammed, special-order, or made-to-order products
  • Gift cards and digital products
  • Sale, clearance, discontinued, or marked final sale merchandise
  • Hazardous materials and goods that cannot safely be returned

Dislike of a flavor, scent, texture, or other personal preference does not by itself establish a product defect. Please ask before opening or testing an item if you are unsure about its eligibility.

04. What if my item arrived damaged, defective, or incorrect?

Please inspect your order when it arrives. If the item is damaged, defective, or not what you ordered, submit a request within 7 days of delivery through Start a Return in your account.

We may request your order number, a description, and clear pictures of the product, packaging, shipping box or mailer, shipping label, and the issue itself. Please retain all packaging during review.

Requests submitted after 7 days or without requested documentation may be denied. An appropriate approved resolution may include a replacement, alternative item, store credit, refund, or another solution based on the circumstances.

05. Can I return candles or home fragrance?

Artisan candles and fragrances are scent-based products, and individual scent preferences vary.

  • Returns based solely on dislike of a scent are not accepted.
  • Fragrance perception is subjective and is not a defect by itself.
  • Lit or used candles are not returnable.
  • Opened or used home fragrance products are not returnable.
  • Minor differences in wax appearance, labeling, color, texture, or scent strength may occur with artisan goods.

If your candle or home fragrance item arrives damaged or defective, submit a request within 7 days of delivery with photos when requested.

06. Who pays for return shipping?

For standard returns, customers are responsible for return shipping unless an item is confirmed damaged, defective, or incorrect.

If My American Goods® supplies a prepaid return label, its cost may be deducted from the refund when applicable. Original shipping charges are non-refundable.

Return postage depends on size, weight, destination, and carrier rates. For lower-priced products, return shipping may approach the value of the merchandise.

07. When and how will I receive my refund?

After an authorized return is received and inspected, we'll notify you whether it has been approved or declined.

If approved, the refund may be issued to your original payment method or as store credit, depending on the item category, return condition, and circumstances.

Please allow up to 10 business days for refund processing after the item is received and inspected. Your bank or payment provider may take additional time to post the refund.

Applicable return shipping, prepaid-label costs, and original shipping charges may be excluded or deducted where permitted by this policy.

08. Can I exchange something?

Exchanges depend on stock availability. Many independent makers produce products in small batches, so a desired size, color, or style cannot be guaranteed.

The quickest option is generally to request an authorized return for an eligible item and place a new order for your preferred version. Return eligibility and any applicable shipping conditions still apply.

09. Can I change or cancel my order?

After checkout, customers have a limited 60-minute window to make eligible changes from the order confirmation page. Depending on the order's status, these may include updating a shipping address, editing items, applying a discount code, or canceling before fulfillment begins.

After this window, the order may enter fulfillment and can no longer be guaranteed eligible for changes or cancellation. Once shipped, eligible merchandise must be handled through our return process.

10. What about comparison purchases?

Purchasing multiple colors, scents, sizes, styles, or variants primarily for comparison, with the intention of returning the unwanted options, can create disproportionate costs for independent makers.

In these situations, My American Goods® may approve store credit rather than a monetary refund, limit the number of items approved for return, or decline returns that impose disproportionate costs, subject to applicable law.

We encourage reviewing measurements, sizing charts, ingredients, specifications, photographs, and product descriptions carefully before purchasing.

11. Why might photos or more information be required?

All return requests are reviewed before approval. For condition-sensitive, damaged, defective, or incorrect items, we may request clear photographs of the item, product packaging, shipping packaging, shipping label, and any visible issue.

We may also request the order number, supporting details, and proof of purchase. Failure to provide required documentation may result in the request being declined.

Do not send a product back without authorization. An unauthorized return may be refused or returned to you at your expense.

12. What about repeated returns or payment disputes?

My American Goods® may review return patterns and account activity and may restrict returns or service where documented excessive returns, repeated comparison purchases, or policy abuse occur, subject to applicable law.

If there is an issue with an order, we encourage you to contact us or submit a return request before initiating a payment dispute so we have an opportunity to review the concern.

We may respond to chargebacks with relevant order details, delivery records, tracking, policy terms, and return correspondence. Abusive dispute activity may result in account restrictions as permitted by law.

13. Additional legal terms and policy updates

EU cooling-off rights, where applicable: Customers to whom applicable EU consumer cancellation laws apply may have a 14-day cooling-off right, subject to legal exceptions and conditions. Potential exceptions include perishables, customized products, and opened personal care goods. Customers may be responsible for diminished value caused by handling beyond what is necessary to inspect an item.

Policy updates: We may revise this policy or make reasonable case-by-case decisions to protect both customers and independent makers, subject to applicable consumer protection laws. By placing an order with My American Goods®, you agree to the applicable policy terms, subject to law.

Ready to Request a Return?

Sign in to your account and choose Start a Return in the left-hand menu. We'll review your request before any return instructions are issued.

Sign In to Start a Return →

Other helpful pages: Return Request Form  |  Shipping Policy  |  Shipping Protection Claims

Every order supports American brands and makers. Thank you for shopping thoughtfully and helping us protect the people behind the products.