Makeup Top Sellers
🏆 Best Seller
PapaBear Naturals
Papabear Tallow Lip Balm - (5 Pack)
$22.95
⭐️ MAG Pick
Pure Good LLC
Tallow Lip Balm
$5.99
❤️ Customer Favorite
VanMan
*New* VanMan's Beeswax Lip Balm
$5.00
🎁 Gift Favorite
Roots And Leaves
Organic Lash & Brow Serum with cold pressed castor oil and pearl powder
$21.99
Curated with Purpose
At My American Goods®, every collection is thoughtfully selected to showcase quality products from American makers, artisans, and small businesses. We're proud to connect customers with brands that still believe in craftsmanship, authenticity, and making things the right way.
Shop All Makeup
200 products
-
Lip Balm: Soothing Healing HerbsVendor:Lip Balm: Soothing Healing HerbsChagrin Valley Soap & Salve- Regular price
-
$7.50 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$7.50
-
TALLOW LIP BUTTER / hydrating lip repairVendor:TALLOW LIP BUTTER / hydrating lip repairWild Haven Skin- Regular price
-
$12.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$12.00
-
Eyeliner Pencil | natural + veganVendor:Eyeliner Pencil | natural + veganTaylor Made Organics- Regular price
-
$16.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$16.00
-
Under-Eye Color Corrector Concealer | Dark CirclesVendor:Under-Eye Color Corrector Concealer | Dark CirclesTaylor Made Organics- Regular price
-
$2.00 $30.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$2.00 $30.00
-
Perfumeria Gal Scented Lip BalmVendor:Perfumeria Gal Scented Lip BalmAsh & Rose- Regular price
-
$12.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$12.00
-
Color Pods - Eye ShadowVendor:Color Pods - Eye ShadowHeaven On Main Street- Regular price
-
$25.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$25.00
-
Hawaiian Pineapple - Natural Organic Lip Balm - Vegan - Plastic-Free .25 ozVendor:Hawaiian Pineapple - Natural Organic Lip Balm - Vegan - Plastic-Free .25 ozKOKOA BOTANICS- Regular price
-
$8.00 $22.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$8.00 $22.00
-
Lip Balm (Aloe + Mint)Vendor:Lip Balm (Aloe + Mint)Cliff Supply- Regular price
-
$5.00 $13.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$5.00 $13.00
-
Antioxidant Lip BalmVendor:Antioxidant Lip BalmAnnmarie Skin Care- Regular price
-
$10.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$10.00
-
Sweet Almond Lip BalmVendor:Sweet Almond Lip BalmBorn To Be Free- Regular price
-
$16.50 $24.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$16.50 $24.00
-
Cloud Cover Cream ConcealerVendor:Cloud Cover Cream Concealerurban farm collection- Regular price
-
$30.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$30.00
-
Eyelash Growth Serum OrganicVendor:Eyelash Growth Serum OrganicButter Me Up Organics- Regular price
-
$24.95 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$24.95
-
Lip&Nip Balm | Softening | Nourishing | SoothingVendor:Lip&Nip Balm | Softening | Nourishing | SoothingApotheke DuJardin- Regular price
-
$8.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$8.00
-
Setting Powder | Heaven On Main StreetVendor:Setting Powder | Heaven On Main StreetHeaven On Main Street- Regular price
-
From
$18.00 - Regular price
-
$128.52 - Sale price
-
From
$18.00
-
Retractable Brow Pencil | brow enhancerVendor:Retractable Brow Pencil | brow enhancerTaylor Made Organics- Regular price
-
$24.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$24.00
-
Hibiscus Lip StainVendor:Hibiscus Lip Stainplant makeup- Regular price
-
$14.00 $22.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$14.00 $22.00
