Sugarhouse Leather

Handcrafted Leather Goods, Made in Milwaukee

Discover Sugarhouse Leather, a family-owned Milwaukee studio creating hand-cut and stamped leather coasters, keychains, magnets, ornaments, luggage tags, custom gifts, and small home accessories with a style that sits somewhere between rustic and refined.

Each design is created in-house and made from thick harness leather, then individually cut and stamped by the Sugarhouse team in its Wisconsin workshop. Because leather is a natural material, every finished piece develops its own character and patina over time.

The assortment ranges from American flags, states, cities, cabins, bourbon and outdoor themes to cheeky sayings, monograms, travel designs, and custom branding, giving the collection an unusually strong gifting angle. Sugarhouse also pours its own apothecary-style candles in-house.

This isn’t mass-produced souvenir merchandise.

It’s real leather, real Wisconsin craftsmanship, and everyday pieces made with personality.

Sugarhouse Leather Top Sellers

Curated with Purpose

At My American Goods®, every collection is thoughtfully selected to showcase quality products from American makers, artisans, and small businesses. We're proud to connect customers with brands that still believe in craftsmanship, authenticity, and making things the right way.

Shop All Sugarhouse Leather

Sorry, there are no products in this collection

Sugarhouse Leather FAQs: Milwaukee Craftsmanship, Harness Leather & Custom Gifts

Where is Sugarhouse Leather based?

Sugarhouse Leather is a small-scale, family-owned leather studio in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Its products are designed and made by the team in its own workshop.

Who started Sugarhouse Leather?

Nick Pennington is the owner and original leather maker behind Sugarhouse Leather. He began leatherworking as a creative outlet after developing an interest in traditional leather goods and making things by hand.

What does Sugarhouse Leather make?

The collection includes leather coasters, keychains, magnets, ornaments, luggage tags, personalized pieces, custom promotional goods, and other giftable leather accessories. The studio also offers hand-poured candles.

What type of leather does Sugarhouse use?

The studio describes its material as thick, premium harness leather selected for its durability and ability to develop a beautiful patina with age.

Are the designs made in-house?

Yes. Sugarhouse says its coaster designs are created in-house using hand-drawn fonts and illustrations, then individually cut and stamped in its Milwaukee workshop.

Does Sugarhouse Leather make custom products?

Yes. The studio creates custom-stamped coasters, keychains, magnets, ornaments, branded gifts, promotional pieces, and location-specific designs for retailers and businesses.

Reviews are in!

4.78 ★ (25620)
Verified

This is our promise

  • American Brand

  • Secure Transactions

  • Verified Reviews

  • Small Business