Coney Island Saucery

Coney Island Saucery brings bold, unforgettable flavor straight from Brooklyn’s boardwalk. Crafted in small batches with real ingredients and serious attitude, these sauces add a punch of personality to every bite. From smoky heat to tangy twists, each bottle captures the spirit of NYC street food—loud, proud, and full of flavor.

Coney Island Saucery Top Sellers

Coney Island Saucery Hot Sauce Trailer Park Boys - Deeecent Hot Sauce 5oz
🏆 Best Seller
Coney Island Saucery

Trailer Park Boys - Deeecent Hot Sauce 5oz

$14.99
Coney Island Saucery Hot Sauce Fallout Vault-Tec Industries Hot Sauce 5oz
⭐️ MAG Pick
Coney Island Saucery

Fallout Vault-Tec Industries Hot Sauce 5oz

$14.99
Coney Island Saucery Hot Sauce Trailer Park Boys - Ricky's Smokes Let's Go Hot Sauce 5oz
❤️ Customer Favorite
Coney Island Saucery

Trailer Park Boys - Ricky's Smokes Let's Go Hot Sauce 5oz

$14.99
Coney Island Saucery Hot Sauce Trailer Park Boys - Green Bastard Hot Sauce 5oz
🎁 Gift Favorite
Coney Island Saucery

Trailer Park Boys - Green Bastard Hot Sauce 5oz

$14.99

Curated with Purpose

At My American Goods®, every collection is thoughtfully selected to showcase quality products from American makers, artisans, and small businesses. We're proud to connect customers with brands that still believe in craftsmanship, authenticity, and making things the right way.

Shop All Coney Island Saucery

Filter
Clear
Sort by
Filter and sort Filter
Filter and sort
Filter

4 products

Clear

4 products

About Coney Island Saucery

Where is Coney Island Saucery from?

Brooklyn, New York. Their hot sauces are crafted in small batches with real ingredients, inspired by NYC street food.
Are the sauces vegan and gluten-free?

Several are labeled vegan and gluten-free, including Radscorpion Venom and Ricky's Smokes Let's Go!. Check each product page for its labels and full ingredient list.
How hot are they?

It varies by sauce. Vault-Tec (pineapple and habanero) is a medium sweet heat, Green Bastard uses jalapeño and serrano, and Raining Blood builds to a Reaper pepper finish for serious heat seekers.
What size are the bottles?

The sauces come in 5 oz bottles.
Do you make collaboration sauces?

Yes. Coney Island Saucery teamed up with the Trailer Park Boys on Deeecent, Ricky's Smokes Let's Go! and the verde-style Green Bastard. It also makes Fallout-inspired sauces (Vault-Tec and Radscorpion Venom) and a Slayer hot sauce.
What's in Radscorpion Venom?

A fiery mix of blueberries, raspberries and scorpion peppers.

Reviews are in!

4.78 ★ (26124)
Verified

The My American Goods® Difference

What We Stand For

American Brands, All in One Place

Every brand we carry is an American business.

Vetted With Care

We read the labels so you don’t have to.

Free Shipping Available

Free shipping is offered by participating brands.

Supporting Small Business

Every order supports American brands, makers, and small businesses.

Discover our story →