Butter Me Up Organics


Organic Personal Care, Handcrafted With Purpose

Discover Butter Me Up Organics, an independent American brand creating organic skincare, body care, baby care, hair care, oral care, herbal products, and everyday essentials with thoughtfully selected ingredients and a commitment to hands-on craftsmanship.

Founded by Jillian in 2008, Butter Me Up Organics began after she struggled to find personal care products that met her standards and decided, simply, “I can make this.” 
From body butters and lip balms to deodorants, herbal salves, shampoo bars, baby care, toothpaste, and more, the collection reflects Jillian’s belief in purposeful ingredients, thoughtful formulation, and quality over shortcuts. 
This isn’t conventional personal care.

It’s independently made organic care built on one maker’s standards, research, and commitment to doing things thoughtfully.

Butter Me Up Organics Top Sellers

Butter Me Up Organics Body VEGAN Organic Sunscreen SPF 45
🏆 Best Seller
Butter Me Up Organics

Vegan Mineral Sunscreen SPF 45

$26.95
Butter Me Up Organics Teeth All Natural Organic Whitening Toothpaste / Remineralizing Toothpaste
⭐️ MAG Pick
Butter Me Up Organics

Organic Whitening Toothpaste

$11.25
Non-Nano Zinc Sunscreen
❤️ Customer Favorite
Butter Me Up Organics

Non-Nano Zinc Sunscreen

$13.95
Butter Me Up Organics Face Eyelash Growth Serum Organic
🎁 Gift Favorite
Butter Me Up Organics

Organic Eyelash Growth Serum

$24.95

Curated with Purpose

At My American Goods®, every collection is thoughtfully selected to showcase quality products from American makers, artisans, and small businesses. We're proud to connect customers with brands that still believe in craftsmanship, authenticity, and making things the right way.

Shop All Butter Me Up Organics

Filter
Clear
Sort by
Filter and sort Filter
Filter and sort
Filter

186 products

Clear

186 products

Show more

Butter Me Up Organics FAQs: Organic Skincare, Ingredients & Everyday Care

What is Butter Me Up Organics known for?

Butter Me Up Organics specializes in organic skincare, herbal body care, baby products, shampoo bars, natural deodorants, lip balms, oral care, herbal salves, and household essentials handcrafted in small batches.

Who founded Butter Me Up Organics?

Butter Me Up Organics was founded by Lynn, who started making organic personal care products for her own family before growing the business into a full line of handcrafted essentials.

Are Butter Me Up Organics products made with organic ingredients?

Yes. The brand formulates its products using certified organic ingredients whenever available, carefully selecting plant-based oils, butters, herbs, waxes, and botanical extracts.

What kinds of products does Butter Me Up Organics offer?

The collection includes:

  • Body Butters
  • Lip Balms
  • Herbal Salves
  • Baby Care
  • Natural Deodorants
  • Shampoo Bars
  • Conditioner Bars
  • Toothpaste & Oral Care
  • Facial Care
  • Household Products
  • Beard Care
Are Butter Me Up Organics products handmade?

Yes. Every product is handcrafted in small batches with careful attention to ingredient quality and consistency.

Who are Butter Me Up Organics products designed for?

The collection is designed for individuals and families looking for thoughtfully made everyday personal care products crafted with simple, organic ingredients.

Reviews are in!

4.78 ★ (25982)
Verified

The My American Goods® Difference

What We Stand For

American Brands, All in One Place

Every brand we carry is an American business.

Vetted With Care

We read the labels so you don’t have to.

Free Shipping Available

Free shipping is offered by participating brands.

Supporting Small Business

Every order supports American brands, makers, and small businesses.

Discover our story →