Amazon is everywhere. It’s quick, convenient, and packed with millions of products. But when you’re looking for something authentic — something made by real people with care, intention, and quality — Amazon often falls short.
That’s why so many independent makers choose not to sell on Amazon. Instead, they keep their products off the giant marketplace, protecting their brand integrity and ensuring that every customer interaction stays personal. At My American Goods, we’ve curated a collection of these hidden gems.
Here are ten authentic American brands not on Amazon — makers who put craft before mass production.
1. Ash & Rose
Based in Massachusetts is a women-owned brand dedicated to sustainable fashion, jewelry, and self-care products. They curate pieces that are ethically sourced, eco-conscious, and designed to tell a story. You won’t find their collections on Amazon — instead, they partner with small retailers and marketplaces like My American Goods to keep shopping meaningful and authentic.
2. Brothers Artisan Oil
This brand redefines men’s grooming with oils, balms, and soaps made from natural ingredients. Brothers Artisan Oil brings old-world craftsmanship into modern routines, perfect for anyone seeking authentic self-care products outside of mass retail.
3. Dr. Watson’s Hair & Body Care
Dr. Watson’s creates classic American grooming goods like pomades and soaps. Each formula is made in small batches, capturing the timeless style of traditional barbershops with a modern, eco-friendly twist.
4. Salacia Salts
Handcrafted in Savannah, Georgia, Salacia Salts transforms southern coastal traditions into luxurious skincare. Their bath salts and scrubs use natural sea salts and botanicals, bringing the spa experience home.
5. Apotheke du Jardin
Rooted in plant wisdom, Apotheke du Jardin blends botanical extracts and oils into artisanal skincare. It’s self-care designed to feel like a ritual — carefully crafted, never mass-produced.
6. Clara & Fritz
Clara Fritz creates elegant skincare and wellness products with an eye for design. Each item feels like a work of art, making daily routines more intentional and beautiful.
7. Plant Makeup
For the free-spirited, Plant Makeup offers edgy, botanical skincare and cosmetics. Think wildflowers, roots, and herbs blended into makeup that feels more like nature than industry. It’s playful, plant-powered beauty you won’t see on Amazon.
8. Poured Goods
Sustainability meets home décor with Poured Goods. Their hand-poured candles combine modern style with eco-friendly practices. Each one burns clean and bright, turning everyday spaces into cozy retreats.
9. Dakota Tallow
Tallow has been used for centuries as a skin-nourishing ingredient. Dakota Tallow brings it back with modern, grass-fed formulas. The result? Skincare that’s deeply hydrating and rooted in tradition.
10. Boathouse
Boathouse draws inspiration from the coast. Their products reflect an easygoing, nautical lifestyle — perfect for anyone who loves the sea breeze and timeless American style.
Why These Brands Aren’t on Amazon
You might wonder why these makers avoid Amazon as the world’s biggest marketplace. The reasons are simple:
- Protecting brand integrity.
- Maintaining fair pricing.
- Staying true to small-batch values.
- Building direct connections with customers.
As Yahoo recently reported, more brands are leaving Amazon to preserve quality and authenticity. By shopping with marketplaces like My American Goods, you’re choosing values over convenience.
Discover More American Brands Not on Amazon
When you shop these makers, you’re not just buying a product — you’re supporting the stories, traditions, and craftsmanship that make America unique.
Explore the full collection of authentic American brands not on Amazon and discover products made with heart.